"Some birds aren't meant to be caged, their feathers are just too bright"- Morgan Freeman, Shawshank Redemption. This blog is from one such bird who couldn't be caged by organizations who mandate scripted software testing. Pradeep Soundararajan welcomes you to this blog and wishes you a good time here and even otherwise.

Wednesday, August 27, 2008

Faking Experience in Software Testing from India to USA via Europe

The entire e-mail conversation between me and someone is available for you without his permission. I have masked his mail id and name to protect his privacy.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

hi,
this is XXXXX from chennai, now married and settled in XXXXXX, USA.
i saw ur blog on testing and found it very useful. i am applying for testing jobs with some fake exp, just wanted to know some complicated bugs u encountered and some show stoppers that u faced. since i was asked this questions in interviews I wanted some experienced person's input.
thanks

Regards

XXXXX

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

To which I replied:

Listen to this : http://www.skilledtests.com/testertested/FIET.mp3 and thanks for spoiling India's name in US.

The industry needs more people like you. Your parents will be so proud of you. By the way I think you would be happy to know that your father also got a job faking.

Thanks,

-- Pradeep Soundararajan

and the conversation continues

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi

You dont have to be so angry for this. I am not saying that I am doing the right thing. I am searching for a job for 9 months. first i put fresher and searched for intern projects, no one called me. then i put 2 years and i searched no called me. then i put 3 years, 2 recruiters called me. I need a job badly for family reasons, I am ready to work my soul off, but nobody is willing to take me trusting my abilities, i am pushed to this situation. its not like i can walk away with a job using fake experience, there are 3-4 level rigourous interrviews where i have to explain all the QA concepts, tell about the projects i have put in my resume ok.... its tougher for me than for someone who has true experience. When i get a job i am not gonna ease off, i have to work 12 hours a day in US to keep that job.
without knowing about my bitter experience, rejections and mental agony, please dont pass judgements.

what are u talking about my father ?

bye

XXXXX


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Hi XXXX,

If you went through the podcast I ,you would know what I meant or why I sound angry.

Its not the situation pushed you to do it, it is you who pushed yourself to do so.

<<>>

The most bitter experience in your life would be faking and not the struggle. Assume you get caught and is black listed, you would never make it big in your life. You might want to focus on your long term goal of becoming successful and not give up.

<<>>

Assume, you discover today that your father faked experience and lied all over his profession, wouldn't you be disappointed to know that?

Tomorrow, your child would feel the same. In this 9 months you could have worked on an open source project, gained true testing experience and be honest to interviewers.

If you appear to win today with faking experience, your future is dark. Testing is about speaking truth and you start a career in testing with a lie.

-- Pradeep Soundararajan

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

hi,

I am daily preparing test cases and test plan for yahoo, google, youtube as a practise.... i cant work as intern since i have to earn money for my son's daycare. Even if they ask for freshers, they want college students, people like me who took a gap for marriage and child birth are left with no choice. so dont jump to conclusions that i am a fruad and cheat.

i am determined to get a job at the earliest, but its the employers who totally crush my efforts by saying that I need to know Perl, VB script, java script, Java, Oracle etc for manual testing, which i am not even gonna use in reality.

Its not that, if i put fake i am immediately gonna get a job, i have to first answer all the questions and prove myself to them, so only if i am brilliant I am gonna get hired. So faking exp is only a small gateway pass I am using so that my resume shows up in the random keyword search done by recruiters.

My son will understand the struggles i have been through surely, but what really matters is if i do my job nicely and sincerely.

Regards

XXXXX

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi XXXX,

I am surprised to know that you have a son to feed and you haven't yet settled in a job. But those reasons wouldn't get any sympathy for you in the IT industry.

By practicing to write test cases to the ones you mentioned, you aren't practicing testing. Instead some open source project would have helped by now to demonstrate that you really did test something.

Also, if you are applying to jobs that ask for VB, Dot Net, XYZ and you either dont have them or dont want to work on them then you are applying for incorrect jobs.

The more time you spend on applying for a wrong job then the less time you have for the jobs you might be suited to.

Did you try LinkedIN?

How about putting up a post in LinkedIN stating that you want a job and blah blah blah is your situation and you don't want to fake your experience. People would appreciate your honesty.


<<>>

If your son is now of the age he understands your problem then I might agree. As your son grows, can you say what he will become?

If you can predict that, get into prediction and you will make more money than being in testing.

I dont know your personal problems but if you have to feed your son till he gets big enough to feed himself and probably you then you might not want to fake. Its tough but not impossible.

How about putting all your test cases online and send a link to the people who have job openings who might look at that want to appreciate your practice and efforts?

There is just one way of being truthful and its the most courageous way.

Thanks,

-- Pradeep Soundararajan

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


hi pradeep,
I just got my work permit a year ago. so since then i am trying hard preparing and studying all QA books, practising the training material, testing my intership project etc.... I dont apply to companies that ask for scripting langs. just to companies which ask for manual testers with exp in test cases and test plans.... so my margin is very very less. I am not a IT degree holder so languages are very unfamiliar to me. so my choice is very less.... with all these drawbakcs, the little i apply is rejected coz of no exp. thats the reason i had to put....
i really need a job to put my son in school.... so when it comes to my son's education or my principles, i chose the former. i know IT industry is merciless, i am telling u all this since u asked why i put fake, do u think i will tell all this to the hiring manager .... they care a damn.
we both are strong in our respective opinions, so lets just agree to disagree...
all the best with ur blog, it was great.
bye

Regards

XXX


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi XXXX

It appears to me that you dont want to learn. For instance there appears to be no tinge of fear in you after me letting you know that you may be jailed for faking. It also might affect your own self respect. I am asking you to be concerned about your own future but the present appears to be more burning for you.

I dont understand how you wanted to be a QA/Test Engineer. I am sure its not your passion but an entry point or maybe you think testing or getting a job in it is easy. Probably that's how someone misguided you.

Jerry Weinberg said something like, "When we are confused our mind falls prey to infertile suggestions from others" and I see it in action in your case, too.

You may make a big name in something you are passionate about in the non-IT space. What organizations ask for is experience and they have the right to ask for it. What people like you do after seeing those ads is to fake the experience hoping that you might get job that way.

I hope your son would prefer not to go to school because despite whatever education the schools you studied has taught, you have grown up to be a faker.

Why send your son to school when all the school teaches is "Speak truth" and "Honesty is the best policy" - none of which you haven't learn? What's the value of education you want to impart when he discovers that he need not practice the good things he learns?

Is IT industry merciless?

You want the IT industry to show mercy against you people? It's business that drives IT and not charity and sympathy towards fakers like you.

I believe in God apart from believing in truth and other good things. I shall pray that you get a job but I shall also pray that you and your son doesn't realize the mistake you are committing for if you or your son ever realizes it in your life, life will become miserable.

Thanks,

--
Pradeep Soundararajan

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

hi

i am passionate about testing, i dont want to go in any other fields which i actually got offers, like bank and teaching. i want IT, i love computers and software and its workings.. thats why i took a course and working so hard. I dont fear fake exp because, i have prepared so hard and i can speak for the years i have faked. the jailing and stuff is irrelevant for me since i have put that i worked in my friends company for which he will give reference.

why are u making this a big issue. did anyone put fake exp and go ahead of u and excelled more than u ? has that deeply affected u ? u seem to really over exagerate stuff. this is the way of life, its the survival of the fittest.... since i had visa problems i was backlagging, now i am in the race too.... at the end of the day hardwork and brilliance counts.... whether u have exp, knowledge or principles it doesnt matter. whether u deliver a quality software before the deadline is what employers look for. as my QA instructor said "its a open secret that everybody at point or another fakes exp"

Regards

XXXXX

hi
lets finish this never ending argument.
i am amidst of huge personal problems, i have no time for honesty. only an empathetic person can feel for me.
goodbye.

Regards

XXXX

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

A software tester from Oracle Corporation in India had e-mailed to me last year, mentioning that I am spoiling India's name globally after listening to the podcast
http://www.skilledtests.com/testertested/FIET.mp3

I replied to him that he should probably be mailing it to people who fake their experience and not me because I am helping people to be aware with the problems of faking experience.

When I search for fake experience in my Gmail inbox, I get to see 67 conversations that has happened between me and about 67 fakers, none of whom wanted to learn its a bad idea and most people did not reply after my first reply to them. I don't know why many testers in India don't consider this as a problem and educate other people and their own college juniors about it. I do that. I have had a person from Hyderabad, India who wanted to travel to either UK or Europe with a fake experience certificate. I spoiled his happiness by letting him know why I think its a bad idea and might not make him successful and he called me up, not to thank but to scold me for the good job I did.

In this context, I have a message to you, your manager, your HR managers:

  • Test the tester: Do not test a tester for his ability to memorize. You might end up hiring a person who is good at memorizing than testing. You might want to give him a software to test and ask him to demonstrate his testing skills. BUT if you'd want to test a tester, your staff should know how to test a tester? You might want to consider going through this video
  • Know the truth about your staff: If your staff doesn't know how to test a tester for testing skills then they don't know testing. You might be disappointed to know they are eating up your profits but might be happy when you get them off.
  • Learn what's good stuff to ask for it: If you don't know what kind of skills attributes testers skills, you would end up asking stuff like Techniques in testing, SDLC Models, Certifications, Tools and other things that are easy to fake.
  • Recognize that it is your problem: Going back to Jerry and Don Gause's question: Whose problem is it? If you think its not your problem, you might think less about it when something goes wrong and you would never know what caused it but might attribute it to something else, try fixing it and end up in pleasing someone that "it worked".
  • Act against fakers and make it public: I know of some organizations in India who have fired people when they found out that they faked and even some went to jail because they put the organization's credibility at stake in front of their customers. All of which is not public news. If you make the news public, you are giving a strong message to those planning to fake to work hard. In turn the community is cleaner than what it is today.
OR

How about faking to people that you didn't know people fake?

You don't need to share or forward this to anyone, its just for you. Keep all good things within you because if you share the community becomes better.

I want to see the community becoming better. Is that a problem?

So, whose problem is it? Its my problem. And remember, not yours. If its mine, I better do something about it.

A problem is the difference between what is desired and what is perceived -- Jerry Weinberg


--
Pradeep Soundararajan - http://testertested.blogspot.com - pradeep.srajan@gmail.com

106 comments:

srinivas said...

Hi pradeep,
thank you very much for providing really valuable ideas for our tester community. today i read your post on putting fake experiance for getting into a good testing job. i my self was in thought of putting some fake exp to get some calls. i have got two years of real exp and currently working as a test engineer. i didn't want to put that extra fake exp and get through screening process and get a more rewarding job than the current one.
the job i currently doing is really boaring and less paying. no assignments, no testing work to do regularly. i really don't have idea about what to do in my current situation. how can i add more value to my current employer and myself.how can i improve my testing skills, so that i don't need to put any fake exp to get a good job and good feeling.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Srinivas,

thank you very much for providing really valuable ideas for our tester community.

In the search of the purpose of my life, I claimed to have figured out that I'd like to benefit the tester community and I belong to that community. I benefit myself and share it with others to enhance my benefits.

i my self was in thought of putting some fake exp to get some calls. i have got two years of real exp and currently working as a test engineer. i didn't want to put that extra fake exp and get through screening process and get a more rewarding job than the current one.

I honestly appreciate you for not faking your experience and being honest. I also hope other readers of my blog would appreciate you for that.

the job i currently doing is really boaring and less paying. no assignments, no testing work to do regularly. i really don't have idea about what to do in my current situation. how can i add more value to my current employer and myself.how can i improve my testing skills, so that i don't need to put any fake exp to get a good job and good feeling.

Does finding bugs make you happy?

If it does then find more ( and if that's the mission )

Do you read books?

How about spending money on Jerry Weinberg's latest book on testing - Perfect Software and other Illusions about Testing

You might want to read a post in this blog where I have written about monotonous testing and who is responsible for that.

If you have been reading my blog then you might have bumped into Rapid Software Testing slides and appendices. Did you try practicing them?

How about teaching other testers the good stuff you learn?

How about educating your management about testing by demonstrating what better testing is?

How about coming down to attend my workshop?

How about creating a testers group in Hyderabad to discuss how to do better testing?

How about blogging your experiences and asking people to challenge your ideas?

How about participating in Test Republic?

How about doing at least some of these?

Treat your job as something that gives you bread and rice and enjoy practicing better testing and practicing it for you never know what is your next challenge in life?

Hang on, learn, keep learning, keep practicing and enjoy the benefits by connecting the dots.

You are a hero to a lot of people now as you avoided faking. So enjoy being a hero for a while and move on to be hero in more contexts.

Roshni said...

Hi Pradeep,
Today this blog has refreshed my memory about an incident of my colleague in my previous work place who faked on experience to get a job in a bigggg company!

My dear colleague had 1.5 years of exp in Java but faked it to 2 years just to qualify the criteria for that well-known company. Later during the telephonic interview in which my dear colleague failed badly...still managed to get a job in that job there becuz my colleague's cousin was working there as a TL & the interviewee was his best friend.

What suprised me actually was this that my colleague's cousin & that PM had deliberately asked my colleague to add fake exp!!!!!

I had a bit hard time to digest this cuz i feel sometimes higher authorities also take part in such filthy stuff. ALl the above 3 specified people are still working for the same company. The only difference is that my colleague now again wants to change job & I hope he doesn't repeat the faking stuff stuff this time.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Roshni,

The story is not surprising me. I don't want to disclose the name but some BIG organizations do this to get people on a specific project.

If I have a large set of non billable resources and a customer demands some skills that my current pool of non billable resources do not possess, I as an organization fake it.

The faking is not just about the individual - organizations do that, too.

I don't see anyone admitting it. I thank you for bringing your story to my blog.

Today's Times of India news paper had an article about the percentage of non utilized resources in large services organization. It's a troublesome figure at around 50 percent to 60 percent.

Roshni said...

Hi Pradeep,
I passed on this blog to a colleague of mine & to my surprise he ended up in saying - "What's the big deal in having fake exp? This all sounds too filmy.... Pradeep's thoughts appear very bookish."

I was stunned for a minute not sure how to react. Then later I replied - "Try out for yourself if you believe that what Pradeep said is all bookish & doesn't make any sense." I now have a challenge in front of me to change the mindset of such people & I believe that with the help of your blog I'll atleast try to make a difference.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Roshni,

I passed on this blog to a colleague of mine & to my surprise he ended up in saying - "What's the big deal in having fake exp? This all sounds too filmy.... Pradeep's thoughts appear very bookish."

Its not his problem so he might have said that. He doesn't consider the idea that the software testing community should become better or is worried about its credibility.

If you look at a lot of testers in forums like orkut software testing communities, yahoo and google groups they often ask a question: "Does testing have a future?" and if they find information it doesn't ( from someone who claims that ) they jump on to something that they think has a brighter future.

Those kind of people are not bothered about helping the community get better if its in a bad shape. It's people like me and you who are bothered about it.

If my knowledge on this is bookish, ask him to show which book talks about faking experience or he considers books to be not so good resources to learn. If he considers books as not so good resources then he hasn't read a good book yet.

I was stunned for a minute not sure how to react. Then later I replied - "Try out for yourself if you believe that what Pradeep said is all bookish & doesn't make any sense." I now have a challenge in front of me to change the mindset of such people & I believe that with the help of your blog I'll atleast try to make a difference.

If you want to make a difference, of course you may use my blog but you may also want to write on on your own.

As you try to change people and learn that they don't want to change - you would end up learning more about yourself.

I don't want to change people but I'd like to see changes happening for the good. I do stuff that might or might not influence people.

If it doesn't influence them then they might not want to be influenced by me but maybe someone else and that someone else could be you.

somu said...

Hi Pradeep
I work in the IT line of a firm where trust and honesty are considered the cornerstone of our business. I have over 8 yrs of exp. The first tester I interviewed and approved(about 2 yrs back) turned out to be a fake!
So here are some stories
1. A cv of 1.5 yrs testing exp interviewed telephonically. My first interview and I asked all the questions that can be learnt. Job gotten the persons' deliverables left a lot to be desired within 1 week. Showed no acumen for being able to learn beyond what's showing on the screen.

2. A sr tester with 4 yrs exp - again interviewed telephonic.
2 rounds of interview - reasonably good with reference to practical problems and situations. Suitable communication skills. Well, not faked experience for sure. Take him in.
1 week after joining
- Can barely speak English. Horrible grammar in writing.
- Does not even ask me questions face to face, so only imagine what he will do with an American client over phone or videocon.
- and God! We are paying him a lot of money!
Surely we did not interview this guy!
He loses his job. I lose my faith on telephonic interviews.
So now - out station candidates have 2 rounds of Surprise interviews. Often the interview comment reads - "Cannot okay unless interviewed F2F."
RESULT - Capable outstation candidates lose.

3- Face2Face interview - 2+ exp.
Good communication, smart person. We start with giving a real situation from our work and ask her to write test steps for it. - Performance poor. Can barely think beyond the login page.
Then start asking about the "tools" experience in her CV. 5 mins of chat and you know she hasn't seen what's written in her own CV. So how did her CV get to my desk. Turns out her husband works in another IT company and placed her CV here through an agency.
I'm furious!

Sadly,( my problem and fault) we don't take action against these cases other than throw them out of office. We should. I should.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Somu,

I loved reading your comment, especially the way you ended it.

This powerful one: We should. I should. I mean.

If a lot of testers like me and you fight against it then I think we can wipe it out.

People think testing is an easy job and so can be faked easily. If we as testers don't test the candidates, we might not be able to take better informed decision about them.

It is the less informed decision that has been helping those fakers to survive and some unlucky ones get caught and are thrown out of jobs.

Mohan PSK said...

To add to faking profiles to make people join a project, sometime companies also fake the telephonic interviews with the client to get resources onboard. Who taught whom to fake? and who taught whom to justify its ok to fake?

I guess companies must get together to form a centralized database of fake resumes. Many people would have thot about this already but somehow its not being implemented. May be we should take some initiative.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Mohan PSK,

Who taught whom to fake? and who taught whom to justify its ok to fake?


Two wonderful questions Mohan.

I guess companies must get together to form a centralized database of fake resumes. Many people would have thot about this already but somehow its not being implemented. May be we should take some initiative.

Yeah. Let's do something on it to help the community get better.

Roshni said...

@ all the honest & passionate testers
Someone has to take a initiative against all these fakers. So lets give it a start through the community & also make everyone realise that testing is not a childs play.

Flights of Fantasy said...

Hi Pradeep

Wht a shame... u are wht ppl say "just talk" and no work. i have read most of your blogs and mostly i feel that you think you feel as if you are the GOD for testing which my dear friend you are not. the blog in which you were discussing about faking experience, if i was in your place first i would have given a helping hand in giving him a "open source project" and then would have explained him everything.
i have 4.5 years of exp which i got by sweating myself and burning my blood day and night. many of my friends have shown fake exp and are presently in US, i do get angry against them but i know what they have gone through. Its very easy to comment on any one dude but very difficult in givving a helping hand.
If you really had the guts to face people you would not be having "Comment moderation has been enabled. All comments must be approved by the blog author". i donot know if my comment would be posted but i hope you would come down to reality. I bet you also would have faked (something which you donot poccess but flaunt that you know about it) some time or the other.
i still like to go through your blogs as they give a lot of thinking stuff.

regards

pradeep

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Flights of Fantasy,

Wht a shame... u are wht ppl say "just talk" and no work. i have read most of your blogs and mostly i feel that you think you feel as if you are the GOD for testing which my dear friend you are not.

Oh, I didn't know that I am not God. Thanks for that.

if i was in your place first i would have given a helping hand in giving him a "open source project" and then would have explained him everything.

Here is a Chinese proverb: If I give you a fish today, you aren't hungry tonight. If I teach you how to fish, you aren't hungry for a lifetime.

i have 4.5 years of exp which i got by sweating myself and burning my blood day and night. many of my friends have shown fake exp and are presently in US, i do get angry against them but i know what they have gone through. Its very easy to comment on any one dude but very difficult in givving a helping hand.


Here is the same Chinese proverb: If I give you a fish today, you aren't hungry tonight. If I teach you how to fish, you aren't hungry for a lifetime.

Plus thanks for letting us know you know a lot of fakers and they are your friends who are enjoying in the United States.

If you really had the guts to face people you would not be having "Comment moderation has been enabled. All comments must be approved by the blog author". i donot know if my comment would be posted but i hope you would come down to reality.

Comment Moderation is for avoiding spam. If you read my blog and you read comments section you might have noticed that I have allowed intelligent people like you post their views on me.

I bet you also would have faked (something which you donot poccess but flaunt that you know about it) some time or the other.

Oh, you know that. Please don't tell it to anyone.

i still like to go through your blogs as they give a lot of thinking stuff.

As I said earlier, you are intelligent. I think you can be more intelligent if you stop reading my blog and also don't ask your faker friends to read any of my posts. It makes them feel sick about themselves.

I don't even know you nor did mention anything specific about you. Despite that it boiled you enough to post this comment which appears to have an anger tone behind it.

Abhinav said...

The industry needs more people like you. Your parents will be so proud of you. By the way I think you would be happy to know that your father also got a job faking.

Wondering what his father has got to do with this ?

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Abhinav,

Wondering what his father has got to do with this ?

Not to my knowledge people let their parents know that they are faking. If they come to know I am sure at least within India, parents would be disappointed about it or might not be so proud about their children working in United States faking.

However, I am trying to help people understand how their next generation would suffer to hear their dad faked!

Abhinav said...

@Pradeep,

IMHO, there are better ways to drive home the point (and you have already done that in your post) than use unnecessary references to family.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Abhinav,

Point taken. Thanks.

Roshni said...

@ Abhinav & Flights of Fantasy,
I think references given about fakers family is to make that faker realise his mistake.

By giving family references I feel Pradeep wanted to make him understand that 'If his parents would done such thing how would he have felt about that.....the same agony his child will be going through when he'll find out how his dishonest was'.

I feel instead of just pinpointing negativity try to take positive things from this blog.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Roshni,

Abhinav's didn't point any negativity but helped me improve on some aspects that I could have done better.

Flights of Fantasy is and was idiotic but he did what he is best at doing - lack of any critical analysis and lack of contextual thinking.

You might want to rethink about Abhinav's comment because I liked the way he drove the point to me.

Lets get out about this family stuff and focus on the message.

Anonymous said...

This is a purely made up conversation in order to promote a blog. The page views must have gone up after this.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

If its made up and for increasing the hits on my blog, why didn't I do it earlier?

If I write to get hits, my blog wouldn't be influential to people or even myself.

Ajoy Kumar Singha said...

Good post Pradeep. Keep it up.

PounderPounded said...

@Poundararajan .. yes you the author.

Do not "pound" way so hard Pounder.. relax. Take a chill pill.

Diffuse your ego a little bit.. it's already the size of Himalayas.

And for God's sake DROP THE FAKE ACCENT!

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Pounder Pounded,

Thanks for your comment. Yes my Ego is already the size of Himalayas and I am trying to grow it bigger. Is that your problem or your family problem that you seem to be so concerned?

Regarding the fake accent, yeah, I love faking accent that irritates people like you.

ramanujam said...

Hi Pradeep,

Don't let any pessimistic ideas to flow in , route the original problem wht she has or wht people participate in debate.

Fake is somewht like corruption flowing under the bed silently.

If anybody wants a living anybody can live with honesty.
But unfortunately Honesty sounds strange to the society,some people have forgot the meaning of the word too.
If anybody is thriving from hunger don't let honesty go away from the path.Can't anybody get a piece of bread in INDIA.I am not preaching understand root of the problem then lets stive together .don't go into personals as problem can be understood by a person who is undergoing ONLY.
i am also testing engineer from HYDERBAD

srinivas said...

hi pradeep
can u let me know how to find and work on open source testing projects

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Srinivas,

can u let me know how to find and work on open source testing projects

The answer is here in the following link: http://tinyurl.com/6rkunt

Anonymous said...

Hi Pradeep'
I have gone through all the comments on your blog.Its nice to see that you are trying to promote ethics honesty fighting against faking etc etc .....but I feel that some where the IT company policies/rules are also the major reason.
A friend of mine who is B.E graduate passed out in Jan 2006 and for 18 months he worked in telecom company as site engineer.learnt testing tools. Now if he is posting his resume as a fresher with a genuine data( worked as site engineer)he is not getting any calls from recruiters as they need only freshers who are still in college campus.A person who has sound knowledge enough to get into an IT company as a fresher is not even called for interviews or should i say not even given a chance to prove his knowledge.

A person with knowledge and talent is sitting at home going through job portals ,hoping and awaiting for that "call" from recruiters and on other hand his peers or colleagues just by shelling out few bucks or "personal contacts"(read in this blog that some one got job coz of very close contacts with the TL) nicely gets a job gets settled in life gets married and is enjoying his life. the other person with all the ethics and morals and a genuine resume is not even picked up or short listed for an interview.
I strongly feel that these IT companies rules like either they should be fresher or should not have a gap are some times very foolish.Very rarely there are walk ins in some companies ....and even a person like my friend gets in there is ever chance of getting rejected because of that so called "gap".IT industry needs talented people so look for them if they have talent and meet the requirements take them in, why to look for that so called "gap".
The society we are living in is not like that of humans it has become like a jungle where the "SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST" phrase rules and people get the fittest tag either by hook or crook.
I just conclude that IT companies should also change the way they select candidates for interviews.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

.....but I feel that some where the IT company policies/rules are also the major reason. and I just conclude that IT companies should also change the way they select candidates for interviews.

When you say IT companies are you talking about the beautiful buildings and boards or people who are a part of it?

It is people who make the IT company and those people include me and you. As long as we keep saying, "They should do it first", they will not be doing it.

If you realize you, me and others are a part of it and it is WE who have to bring in the change, you might be able to bring in the change.

My blog, writing and podcast against faking experience has changed quite a few minds. I am doing my bit but unfortunately there are A$$ H()!&$ who misguide their juniors and run businesses who allow these things to happen.

Unless you start they wont bother. It starts with you and not with them.

A person with knowledge and talent is sitting at home going through job portals ,hoping and awaiting for that "call" from recruiters and on other hand his peers or colleagues just by shelling out few bucks or "personal contacts"(read in this blog that some one got job coz of very close contacts with the TL) nicely gets a job gets settled in life gets married and is enjoying his life. the other person with all the ethics and morals and a genuine resume is not even picked up or short listed for an interview.

If a person claims to be talented and isn't getting a job then he isn't talented enough. There are umpteen number of ways to shine.

Truth is hard and that's why not everyone of us speaks truth.

Read through the whole post again in detail.

Anonymous said...

hi Pradeep,
You replied quite well about certain people who misguide their juniors and that if person is talented there are ways to shine....
I was actually expecting an answer about the rules of the recruiters or the HR department....
Very genuinely and sincerely I want to know "why do they consider that *gap* as a negativity.Is that so important that a resume is not even short listed for an interview.

One more request ....Can you please suggest some of those umpteen ways to shine for a fresher and find a chance to get shorlisted for interview.

( I did not tell that my friend is an expert I again say he is just a fresher with sound knowledge enough to get a job at an entry level.)Even if I think to the worst and assume that my friend is not even fit for the entry level who is the right person to say "you are not fit even as a fresher and you dont have knowledge" ? The recruiters or the interview panel are right ones to assess a candidate.
I would also like to say that its not just about people who are faking with experience it has to do a lot from the recruiters and the Hr people also.They should also maintain certain ethics and morals. Through out the blog mostly the job seekers are getting blamed what about the recruiters are they maintaing the morals. The so called term"BACKDOOR ENTRY" is all with the recruiters! How shamelessly they take money and recruit people.
There is a set of people who are responsible for shorlisting candidates for interview.Do they even realise how important part they are playing in a persons life.They just go through the resume if they find
-gap = reject
- previously contract based job = reject
- not 60% aggregate = reject
so on and so forth
Change should come from both the sides the recruiters as well as from the job seekers.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

Change should come from both the sides the recruiters as well as from the job seekers.

When Mahatma Gandhi wanted to bring a change in India, he changed himself first and the rest followed.

123 said...

@ Pradeep

U son of Bitch First of all u know wht's going on in IT companies n don't blame on job seekers u idiot

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@123,

U son of Bitch First of all u know wht's going on in IT companies n don't blame on job seekers u idiot

If the post has irritated you so much then you must be a faker. My mom never gave birth to cowards and fakers.

123 said...

@ pradeep

I am not Faker.... i am working as SAS programmer n certified SAS programmer n ur way of thinking is to worst.... don't think that ur best u have attitude prob, U know in India how many Engineers r coming out every year..... r every person getting job after they finish there graduation.... there r so many politics r going even in IT Companies also...

one question to Mr. Pradeep..

One of my friend completed his graduation n working in Airtel as RF Engineer for 2 years.... Now he wants to shift into software,learn JAVA n even completed Certification will he get job as fresher.... No way companies won't take him as fresher ... wht he has to do?

U said every person has to change...1st of all Mr.Pradeep Change ur attitude

Don't think that ur best.....
ur worst 1st of all u have to change....

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@123,

If you think you are smart, you'd be interested to know that you aren't. And as you are convinced that I am thinking of myself as best ( compared to people like you ), read the follwing:

As per my stats, it appears you searched for "testertested fake" to reach this blog post and comment with harsh abusive words. I have recorded your ip address, location and mac address, Windows 2003 server machine, running Firefox to post this comment. I can pass this on to cyber crime police of Hyderabad ( the place you currently are ) and pass it on to Southern Online Services ( your internet service provider ) who can track you down in one day and as per the cyber crime laws you can be under jail for abusing others over internet. The words you used in the above comment is sufficient for cyber crime police to get convinced about it.

Isn't that cool, you certified idiot?

Now answering your questions, "U know in India how many Engineers r coming out every year..... r every person getting job after they finish there graduation.... there r so many politics r going even in IT Companies also..." --

Is the solution to fake?

Shouldn't the solution be stop producing babies so that in future there are as many engineers as there are jobs?

Before you bother about others' attitude be careful in not exposing your stupidity in public.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@123,

Forgot to mention that on Republic Day of India, your idea of supporting people to fake is a great credit to all those people who struggled for freedom for India. Freedom to fake - Wow! Sounds great.

Your parents should be proud of you and the politicians in India must be already proud of you by now.

Anonymous said...

Hello Sir,
U are replying quite well to questions and comments but u did not answer a few which I asked, your answers would be of immense help to the readers of this blog.

1.Why do recruiters overlook the talent or genuineness of a candidate/resume if they find the "GAP" in the career graph. A telecoms engineer will naturally work in telecom industry naturally, that should not stop one to consider a career in IT field.So is that gap so much given a weightage.

2.Please tell us some of those umpteen methods to shine so that job seekers like us can get shortlisted for an interview.

3.A few of counseling sessions OR WORDS not only to job seekers but also for people who are in the management level also(who encourage the BACKDOOR ENTRY) through you blog so that they may also get influenced through your honesty talk.

4.As you said(the MAHATMA GANDHI QUOTE) change should come from ourselves first. Expecting a change from people is nothing but changing ourselves . As a job seeker I changed myself I will not put fake experience to get a job.I will wait until vacancies are announced for a fresher like me in this recession period.
5.So what kind of change did Mr.Pradeep Soundarajan bring in himself other than preaching in blogs and talking with people over coffee.You conduct workshops so i assume that you must be at the management/higher level in testing field.
Other than blogging about ethics and morals, in practicality what kind of changes did you try to implement in the selections or interviews, amongst your staff, using your position and authority.Your answers would definitely influence the readers who are at the management level.
6.What is your opinion about the reference system that is seen now a days.A resume that is sent with reference is selected and the same resume without a reference is not selected!!! So a person with no reference has no right to get a place in the interview.I feel its a bad practice everyone does not have excellent references in every company.
7.Does the company you work for encourage taking in of freshers?
I hope the high and personal contacts kind of influence does not happen in your working place....how can it happen when PRADEEP SOUNDARAJAN present.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

Kindly go through "The bad state of software testing interviews in India" presentation PLUS my progress reports plus my other posts to know what changes I have been able to bring in.

Also read "Hands on testing training - The change we need" post to understand about the things I have been trying to bring in.

In recession times, if you are extremely skilled ( or you build them up ) you wouldn't have to wait or bother the next time there is recession. Most lazy humans prefer short cuts and you know that becoming extremely skilled is not for lazy humans and hence they prefer faking.

When they get caught, they also get blacklisted forever and they dont say all this in public because they are cowards.

I would suggest you carefully read the posts that I suggested to get answers to your question.

Krishna said...

One thing I can tell Pradeep the great real time real person...Stop shitting people with your stupid thinking and ideas....If you ever look at your past family history you would find that your ancestors must have cheated faked and looted soooooo many Indian people and thats the reason you must have even studied, where as at the same time millions of Indians were dying of hunger.
It would have been great if you would have given up(or never used it) all the illegal wealth and knowledge ur forefathers accumulated for you and started from the scratch i.e as some poor unlucky Indian (which you wont for sure)..

It only helps if you have such Blogs after you do a self assessment ..
Dont shit people by telling that to Test software you need to be extraordinary..
Anyone in this world can do any work given the opportunity and training without any dirty politics involved..
If its survival of the fittest,you arent any more fit than the XXXXX guy here...You are one of those guys who would lick suck and kill for your superiority over others,change your mindset or your soul would perish

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Krishna,

Stop shitting people with your stupid thinking and ideas....I am just exposing how stupid I am and how brilliant some people who comment on my blog are. This blog is just a platform for that. I cant take out this natural platform where I want to expose how stupid I have been growing.

It is wise not to read stupid material.

If you ever look at your past family history you would find that your ancestors must have cheated faked and looted soooooo many Indian people and thats the reason you must have even studied, where as at the same time millions of Indians were dying of hunger.You mean everyone cheated and now some might not be doing that?


If my ancestors did that, I oppose that too however I cant go and fix the past but might have some influence over the future.

Why are you supporting those fakers?

Are you one such?

Anonymous said...

Hi

U r doing a great job for testing community. A person XXXXX from USA started with a doubt........Without clearing that the conversation gone in different way and ended....

Can we the answer for that atleast now?

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

Without clearing that the conversation gone in different way and ended....

Can we the answer for that atleast now?


The answer is : Faking is a fantastic way of lowering your self esteem and making your children feel ashamed of being born to you and your parents for giving birth to you. If that is what your mission of life is, go ahead.

Anonymous said...

Hi Pradeep,
I have seen your posts. First of all you have a lot of analytical thinking.It is very nice of you raising a concern about testers community although I don't like that you want to improve certain "Community" only. The moral questions you raise are more subjective. Are the only testers faking? Is only India Faking? was not there any business that faked many things? In fact each and every advertisement we see of a business is a fake. This topic is ceaseless and opens many more questions. I think faking is not specific to India and not specific in Testing or IT or electronics etc. why don't we question business tycoons who fake many things in many ways to get a business. All this does not mean that i support fake but at the same time i have so many ethical and moral questions to be answered myself/by life/by some one who did every thing perfect in life. There are people who were extra ordinarily talented but were not recognized just because of not having commercial (qualification/exp)things. In US,UK if you are talented you go through a test and get the job but in India certain qualification and certain experience people only get a job. of course if we open these type of arguments it is never ending in life. Like a terrorist A fake experience guy may support himself and may raise 1000 challenging questions. All what we need to think is which is bearable and which is not. Edwards Deming,Father of quality control was not recognized by US but by German. Does it mean that he was not talented enough to be recognized by US?. what makes me happy is you are intelligent and working with big guys like James and Michael. I personally love
Cem kaner and Jamesbach services for testing field. what makes sad is the rude of way of expressing your feelings. Keep up all your good stuff.

Anonymous said...

Hi Pradeep..I like your 'Fake' accent...see you have faked something you don't have !!!!

cheers fella

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous (which is your unfaked true name)

I like your 'Fake' accent...see you have faked something you don't have !!!!

I wish you heard me speak from childhood and yet said this. Indians speaking American accent if faking?

Anonymous said...

@Pradeep...unfaked and true means the same..didn't have to use it in same sentence..

I wish I had heard you earlier to convince myself you aren't faking...

Its only today I have stumbled upon your blogs and you are doing well for yourselves...

Am sure you didn't start as Test Consultant in your first job post your grad..either the role was different or you have given yourselves a 'Test Consultant' to look good in your resume..

No regrets fella..good on you to be doing well...

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Newbie_Anonymous,

I did get hired as a Test Consultant. You seem to have questions for which spending a while and googling can help you find answers.

Tarun K said...

It is saddening to see that people are not even ready to accept that there faking in unethical.

Between some asked about work on Open Source Project, We have lots of work Pending on development of Selenium, whatever you could help with Coding, Development, proof reading etc. Just drop a mail to -

https://groups.google.com/group/selenium-developers?hl=en
about your interests.

I myself have worked on Documentation of Selenium.

~ T

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Tarun K,

Have you looked at weekendtesting.com ?

Anyone could approach them for help in testing and there are lots of open source projects that testers volunteer to test through it.

Anonymous said...

Interesting topic re the fake resumes. I believe most people around globe fake their experience at some point to progress.

But talking about parents and kids of the resume fakers is a cheap hit "below the waist".

@Pradeep why don't you ask all the big IT companies (TCS, WIPRO etc), why they have to fake some resumes to get their staff working in the projects for some prestigious clients.

Before you try and counter the arguments with your Rhetorical questioning skill, "whether I fake or not is immaterial", I am just standing up to some of your unfair views.

Tarun K said...

Not yet, would see soon.

~ T

Anonymous said...

hey pradeep

one simple thing
god will hate u for whatever u did

forget about ethics andmoral in faking experience
abusing people and thier familes
to which moral and ethic it will come

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

one simple thing
god will hate u for whatever u did


Oh the Spiritual soul, if you believe so much in God, why support fakers and why remain Anonymous?

Anonymous said...

Hey Soundarjan,

I was just browsing the net and found your blog.I was going through the topic you were discussing about the fake experience.

1)All the points you were talking about family and stuff signifies how matured you are and I am wondering how people like you are coming to this Software profession.
(Can come only through testing)

2)I am not completely supporting the fake experience but when you have the talent and the people are not giving a chance to prove that then there is no problem in doing so.
3)I am writing this because today i got some time to waste it & people don't waste your precious time in this idiotic blog.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

All the points you were talking about family and stuff signifies how matured you are and I am wondering how people like you are coming to this Software profession.
(Can come only through testing)


You don't read things completely. If you had read the comments section, you wouldn't have posted your above two comments.

2)I am not completely supporting the fake experience but when you have the talent and the people are not giving a chance to prove that then there is no problem in doing so.

Wow! You rock.

3)I am writing this because today i got some time to waste it & people don't waste your precious time in this idiotic blog.

If you have some time to waste go do something useful in it. For instance, your English could be something that might need improvement. You write "i" instead of "I" and more such :)

Tarun K said...

@Anony -

Your statement - "(Can come only through testing)" is demeaning to all of us!!!
I hope u pocket it.

~ T

Selim Mia said...

@Anonymous,
(Can come only through testing)
people like you who can make such irritating statement!!! it is expected that people like you can't respect others, who even don't respect his own name and stated as Anonymous to the audience and give his worthless comment because you don't have such identity to establish!
Wish for your improved encephalon ;-)

Anonymous said...

Some people like PS do not live in the real world looking at what is really happening, instead live in their childwood. Do not you see so many people get into big corps without interviews and some even not submitting their CVs. There is a lot to know for you on that side of the coin. You seem to be bothered from your life's success point of view.

I have seen people like you who have been so sucessful in their lives to support this kind of stuff. But i am sure these people mostly lived their lives for themselves. They do not spend a minute or penny if there is a calamity in their surrounding.

So , there are lots of people with diffenrent abilities which you donot. You are only fit for testing. nothing else.

Anonymous said...

Hi Pradeep,
I Just want to Know how many Total years of Experience you have in Testng. Can you Swear, you dint use even 1 month as Fake in your entire carrer.??

Anonymous said...

Please Ban this Blog. Fit for nothing blog.

Anonymous said...

Who the fuck is Pradeep Soundararajan in giving advice n writing the bullshit conversation. Its company's job to find the truth whether exp s fake or not !
Don give ethics lecture here. Giving assumptions and writing blogs is the easiest work ,it seems.
Here is an assumption for you Pradeep , what if ur son r daughter caught in porn clip ?Does that mean they inherited ur qualities !

MADHUSUDAN said...

Pradeep,

I have mixed feelings about the information in this topic.

Firstly, I very much appreciate you for your helping hand and trying to explain the IMPACT of fake experience in their FUTURE.
I have seen many people who got job with fake experience remained handicapped, similar to what somu said in his comments above (Does not even ask me questions face to face, etc).

In my 10+ years of experience (nothing fake) in IT industry, I have never seen a person searching for job more than a year if he started his job search with hard work and without putting fake projects experience.

Most of the freshers start their job search with fake projects (without they working on the semester project) and they fail to clear the interviews again and again for years. And still they say companies are not giving the jobs for the right talented people.

Many freshers who worked on their project work either in companies or open source projects, are able to clear the interviews and settling. Everyone have to realize the impact of their present efforts.


Secondly, there may be true gaps in the resume but if he is not faking experience, being us on the other side of the interview table we need to give the opportunity to the right talent.


Thirdly, I surprised to read the information from you and others comments like maintaining db of fake experienced people, thinking of companies need to take more severe action, sending to jail, etc. These seems to be very strange ideas.

The people who are not getting the jobs for longer time, they did a mistake of not learning from their failures. We can help them to realize like what you are doing already.
If they are not realizing let them take their own time for realization, no need to think so serious. There are many things in our system (current headlines in every newspaper) which needs serious thinking if we can.

Finally, it is very disappointing to see the unmatured Anonymous comments hiding behind the scenes. They neither understand the positive things from your effort nor impact...


Best regards,
Madhusudan

kamesh said...

U say don't keep fake experience. One thing tell me does the industry is taking the people who are genuine? Only 30% hardly. Every company is going for few campus and hiring the people and what about the other people who don't have campus placements? what they have to do they have to wait until their chance comes . One year two years.Now when the year passes the company's are not considering the previous year candidates as freshers.Then what these people have to do. How many days they have to dependent on parents.You might argue with there are other jobs. How many jobs are there and how many people are there for every 1 job more than 100 people trying.and even with the company's they are calling the most of the people who are having referrals in the company's. How many have references some may have. Does these people have to wait until they get the opportunity.This is not all good. Being the bank of the river every one will say swim like that swim like this.Guys don't remember how they had come to bank of the river.
even the company's know they are fake then why are they taking? The company's are even fake they are cheating the clients. I have even experienced it. when I have 1year of experience my company said to my client I have 4yrs of experience. Does the company is not cheating the client for the money and work.
not only this company or that company does that 99% will do this. when the company's are only doing this why cant people.....

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Kamesh,

You seem to be sympathetic to fakers because you are seeing one side of their life - struggle to get a job. I am asking you to see the other side i.e. if they get caught they'd be black listed by all NASSCOM big, medium and small companies.

So, the quest to get a job through fake would turn them to misery of a lifetime.

Regarding your statement of companies cheating the client - do you have the guts to reveal which company was that?

If you had taken it up to NASSCOM, you would have been awarded man. You missed a wonderful opportunity to be a hero for India.

Well, you think you cant change it? I don't have fear so I dare to change things and I encourage you to dare.

Its because the fakers survive genuine people fail to get a chance.

kamesh said...

Common man... if u see like that 90% of people will not get jobs.If they didn't get jobs automatically man power get reduced and work will be more on genuine people.Instead of working 8hrs /day people have to work 16 to 18hrs /day for 365 days.Every company knows that they have fake experienced people. In One meeting they said that In company's 60 to 80% of the people are joining in company's with fake experience but at they same time they are able to deliver the deliverables in time with good work then what is the need for throwing out. There are certain reasons that he didn't get the job in time.We are happy with the people and the work.This one was told in one the MNC.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Kamesh,

Did you fake?

Anonymous said...

this conversation does make any sense at all.. can you ppl shut ur ******* ...

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

this conversation does make any sense at all.. can you ppl shut ur ******* ...

You seem to act as though this conversation is happening in your blog and you are being disturbed.

If its not your blog, stop reading it.

Anonymous said...

@ Pradeep Soundararajan

i have Unsubscribe ... tx :)

kamesh said...

nope....

kamesh said...

n u didn't answered to my ?n

Rajesh said...

Simply put, the author of this blog, is an irresponsible person who exposes the privacy of a person who trusted in him.

To the Author:
If you had any kind of real sense belonging or attachment to the country and profession, you will never talk about parents and you could have actually brought out the topic without mentioning the name (in the tape) or the location (right here).

This guy came and confessed to you and you exposed him (his name, location and what not), dont you feel a sense of guilt? to make your blog popular you will do anything and everything?

Anyways... hopefully with time you will realise the magnitude of your mistake, of exposing someone who trusted in you. The mistake the other person did (faking experience) is much much smaller than yours... reading your comments I think you are in no mood to listen. I was so shocked to see such breach of privacy that I wrote this comment.

Last but not the last thing that came to my mind... you might have faked the entire mail and conversations for the purpose of this blog, in which case you broke the spirit of this whole article even before you wrote the first word of it.

May lord give you some sense of responsibility and respect for other's privacy.

Rajesh

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Rajesh,

I breached the privacy? OK, then tell who the guy is?

People like you, just come and read this one post and conclude the whole thing about me, which indicates your education.

You say that I faked this post? Funny man. As though there are no fakers in the world who would email to a blogger like me seeking help for projects, I had to create one.

If I had written an alien story, you have all rights to think its fake but I wrote about humans like you and me who are fallible. The world knows there are many fakers today and I haven't written any fantasy out here.

sudhire said...

Hi Pradeep,

First of let me tell you are the one of the best blogger i have ever gone thru. Honestly speaking your blog attracts me like the magnet. I even some times keep reading it thru my mobile also. Superb stuff. its very usefull for the testers like me.

BTW can you tell me where i can get the book "Jerry Weinberg's latest book on testing - Perfect Software and other Illusions about Testing". i Had been to Sapna Book House, the guy there is telling like this book is not available in india.... any help?

Thanks,
Sudhir Bhat.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Sudhir Bhat,

Thanks. You could now download Jerry's books as an ebook. Just google for the ebook or go to Prism book shop and they have a stock of Jerry's books or they may get it for you.

Santy said...

Hi Pradeep,
I have to take interviews tomorrow and hence was searching for some questions which could help me screw the canditate. From some link, I have diverted till here and am happy I reached here.I have never worked in a CMM level company but have slogged last four to five years in the products or projects which I have worked. I have kept aside testing strategies or testing methodologies but rather put them in a mixer and have used what I could to get the max of issues for my to-be -delivered product or project. At the end of these four years, I have been successfule for being a lead from last 2 and half years but thoughts started getting into my head after reading your blogs , that , I have missed learning or doing things the right way. I always had blockages in form of delivery time, company's wish for the required quality in their products and more times my laziness not to look things out of my project. These all things lead me to knowing large extent of things of product and project and bringing less varieties or changes in strategies for betterment of the project.I feel to be lost sometime. Am i Really Lost? What do you feel like? If you happen to ready my blog, will be happy to see your reply?
Thanks,
Santy

Mugen said...

Hi Pradeep,

I have been working as a black box tester for more than 3 years in Bangalore. Sometimes I look for another job in the industry and go for interviews. But in all these interviews I am always asked for 1 programming langauge/ 1 scripting language/ 1 non-functional testing area expertise ("such as automation, performance, stress, soak etc"). I explain that I only know Java basics but haven't worked on programming. I am looking to work as a black box tester and I have done a very good job in that in the past.

To this they start asking me some queries in Java that I usually don't know like "what is serialization? what 3 things can you not serialize? what is a transient variable? what is the difference between a vector and arraylist?" etc.

What are your comments on this? What skills do you think are important for a long term career in black box testing?

Shailesh Gohel said...

Hi Pradeep.

I quite often read your blog and i really appreciate all your blog posts. First time i am putting comment in your blog.

Yeh you have point out very true thing about "Fake" experience in our industry. I personally feel that such people who show some fake experience and join IT industry are ruining their as well other people's career. Because of such Fakers now recruiters have some policies that sometimes stop a genuine candidate to be selected.

But in this case our Ms. XXXX is doing right to showing some fake experience in her resume to get the job. As she is doing it to ful fill her personal needs. Its better to get an entry to an IT company instead of washing dishes to some McDonald store or create bill for some DESI grocery store. But it should be for the entry level only and should not continue for life time. But practically i think that its OK to get a first job when you in a country like USA where your day to day expenses are quite high.

I have even observed during my academic career that students need to create projects in each semester and 90% of them just got some ready made project and submit with some alteration in Name and all. And after graduation they showcase such project in their resume(Like a compression application like winzip in Java - When the fact is that guy is really not capable to implement the compression algorithm in java). So from the college time only people start faking the experience and the result we see is at the time of Product release :)

Stop Faking the experience.

Thanks,
Shailesh

maha said...

Hai Mr.Paradeep,

I have completed BE in EEE.Currnetly i work as an CRM EXE wherein my role is to test the application for bugs and intiate the bugs to the developer to resolve them.As our company has developed their own CRM through a software consultant my job is to monitor the uasge of this application at our client place and finding bugs.So i feel that taking a proper course in Software testing would improve my knowledge on this and i wanna fix it as my career too.But im worried that am i too far to learn rite now on software testing because ive completed my degree in 2005.Marriage and birth of my son took a long back from working field.So please gudie me whether i can take a testing course and choosing a testing as my career.Since im from a technical background i need to learn bacis to learn testing.Please guide me.

Regards,
Maha

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Maha,

From what you have described you already are doing testing. Additional training can always help you do better but it is equally important who is training you.

I would suggest you get in touch with people like Parimala ( http://curioustester.blogspot.com ) and seek out her help to mentor you. That is much better than most traditional training.

Anonymous said...

hi
I dbelieve in what i see and came across an incident where 1 of my friend get job by faking 2yr exp with 2.4lpa still he is working on big project without any exp
so i think its on ones believe and a shortcut to achieve ur goal
ppl lie many times in their life

Eric Schafnitz said...

From Book (Lessons Learned In Software Testing ) by Kaner, Bach and Pettichord
"If you have integrity, you can develop your competence. If you've lost your integrety, your competence won't matter"

Prasanna said...

I see a more systemic problem in India rather than people showing fake experience. People show fake experience in all the technologies, but more in testing as its considered to be a easy subject to fake.
The criteria set up by IT companies in India for recruitment is the real reason for so many fake experiences in IT companies. They look for only Engineering or MCA graduates (sometimes with certain percentage of mark)
The experience must be in the relevant technology and for particular years to qualify for attending the interview.
In reality we don't need a Engg or MCA degree to be a good developer or tester. Above average IQ (what we can normally expect from a high school guy) is good enough to get an entry.
Regarding experience, anyone worked in any field, If interested to learn can learn and do the job. Learning testing or any language or technology doesn't matter on your past experience.
No company(except a very very few exceptions) accept candidate even for interview If they don't have either the particular degree or relevant experience. So genuine candidates interested to make IT as a career are left with very limited options.
Having said that I don't support faking experience, but the companies need also to change their mind set on this. I have met and worked with quite a few people(most of them from outside India) who are doing very good job in IT with neither an IT degree nor an IT background.

rohan said...

see i met a one case in my personal life . one of my friend done btech and he got a job in mnc company but due to economic recession, he didnt receive call letter. so he decided to mtech after his mtech now he is searching job as a fresher . but no software compny is willing to take mtech freshers. more over he had 1 year gap between btech and mtech . now he kept fake of 3 years and he joined in a mnc company nw he is able to survive and earning 7 lakhs per annum . he kept the fake because of the behaviour of s/w companies only .. nw a days they are not giving jobs for second class people . it doesnt make any sense that people who r having distinction are great people who r having second class are poor . software companies have to give chance for that kind of peoples also..

Virat said...

Pradeep , I agree with you , but from what i have observed about the IT industry , specifically the Indian IT that your speaking skills count more than your dev or testing skills.

I have seen people getting promoted just by talking their way out

Fake it till you make it seems to be the winning strategy now a days...

Anonymous said...

Hi Pradeep,

You blog is nice and informative.

I have been in testing for the past 8 years.I was working as a software developer and later opted to be in testing [automation] after 3 years of my career. I pretty much know what you are talking about.

However, I totally agree with all the points that you have mentioned in this thread..ya some people may find offended but who cares until others understand the moto of the conversation happening here...

I would suggest not to drag parents/families in between the conversation. It has got nothing to do with them and their efforts/up bringing.

Again, it's up to you.

I reached this blog in search of information to get a Job of my caliber in US. I have a very good job in one of the biggest MNC with a reputed designation but feel I am kind of under paid. Do you think it's a better to migrate?

Anonymous said...

you guyz are so honest and god fearing....here first comment is poor man he sincerly agreed that he is faking his experience. why you guyz are making big scene out of it....it's nothing wrong in faking your experience...if you are not capable they are not going to hire you...for bread and butter you can tell lies dharmaraju him self said that.....dont make big scene out of it....end f the day do work to the amount paid...if you are not cpable they are not going to keep you for ever:)

webmag said...

Hi Pradeep,

I am a Software Tester currently working UAE.I happened to come by your blog while I was searching for some testing related articles to readthrough. Read one of your old posts in the blog regarding fake experiences...In fact I was surprised at the amount of negativity people showed towards you for not supporting the 'fake experience' case.Most points mentioned by the people in the Blog are true about people who have faked their profile enjoying in US. I had one experience in my first organisation where a person who had joined newly to my project turned out have faked his testing experience...The person had become well acquainted with all of us in a short amount of time, but when this incident happened , he had to leave the company over the weekend without saying a 'bye' to all of us. This incident made me realise one thing,that a lie can save you today or tomrrow ...but never in the long run

So faking your experience may save your present ..But not your future ..it will always do harm.

Regards,
Mahesh

Anonymous said...

I only had 4 months experience but faked it to 2 years and got a job in a major IT company in India.

Seriously.. ethics in this capitalistic world? This blog writer is a fucking nerd. I didn't know there are still such retards in this world.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

Yup, I am a fucking nerd and you are the holy coward. I knew cowards like you exist that is why I wrote this post.

You would come back and read this comment, that is how insecure you are.

Tarun Kumar said...

The anonymous posters are so manner less. @Pradeep, why do you even have to publish their comments?

Anonymous said...

Hi all,

I got few questions to all of you people who think faking your resume is not ethical.
I'll come to question later, but let me begin with small background.
I am a non IT graduate from India, but have done few courses in IT and used to work as developer in a small town local IT company.
Around 5 years back I migrated to Canada. Initially I tried to find a job in IT.
No body was ready to hire me even for entry level position, as I had no Canadian experience/references and didn't want to fake my resume either.
I worked in a factory for more than a year. Then, I quit that job and decided to go to school(yes, they call it school).
Received bunch of recommendation letters from teachers and college president.
Graduated with highest grades and hopes, launched my self in job hunt.
The first role I got was a Tech support in Call center.
That was very stressful; worse than working in a factory and I realized that I can't survive at this job for long time.
Let me tell you here that I not very young (turning 40 very soon) and have family.
At this age people are well settled and for me this was a fresh start in Canada in a job like that.
It even gets more frustating when you see the people have zero IT skills are making four times money than what you get.
Reason? they faked their resume. I decided to do that too. Call me a quitter or holy coward or whatever.
Now its been more than a year, I am working with a top company as a contractor.
I think I have done well on this job and have gained respect and trust in this year.
I am not trying to justify what I have done and I still have the guilt inside.
My question is too all of you guys what could I have done better?
Now if I want to un-fake my resume, what can I do?

Thanks in advance for any suggestion.
Kay

Eric Schafnitz said...

When I decided to enter the Software QA industry after 14 yrs in IT Support I found a company that valued my skills that I already had while being willing to train me in the art of software testing. I now work fulltime as a software QA Analyst at that same company and love my job.
Most important to me is that my resume is an accurate story of the journey I have taken in my IT career and shows that you only have to work hard and prove yourself to succeed.

The short sighted people who fake their resumes harm the industry as a whole but most of all they hurt their integrity making any real progress harder in the future because they spend their time looking over their shoulders scared someone will find out their dirty little secreat.

Tlo all you fakers , Come clean, take the consequences of your actions, and start afreash with a clean concience.

Anonymous said...

Dear Pradeep,

Please do suggest me:
I am Chethan work as Database Consultant since 3 yrs but having knowledge & interested in software testing field, but as everyone suffering same no openings but ready to work as fresher also they will see my past education percentage but not ready to provide me a job. Just suggest me how to crack this puzzle to get job atleast as fresher in Software testing Industry send your valuable response to emailchethankumarpr@gmail.com

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous/Chethan,

Find my email id and send me your profile. Moolya is hiring freshers and I can see if I can suit you in. The timing of your comment seems to be good, let me also see how both our luck works out to be.

Anonymous said...

Dear Pradeep,

Thanks for you kind concern & support please can you provide your email id & I will send my genuine resume. Please help me out.

Regards,
Chethan.
emailchethankumarpr@gmail.com

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Chethan,

If you can find my email id, please send me your profile.

Anonymous said...

Hi Pradeep,

Need ur help.I dont have prior exp in testing but interested to move into testing field.everyone tells me that i wont be able to get a job as freasher.what to do ???

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous,

Do you see the difference? You are talking about a career and people around you are talking about a job. You must watch the movie The Pursuit of Happyness.

Anonymous said...

hi praadeep,
i need a job very badly..all are telling to me to keep fake experience.
what i want to do??
I am in confussion stage...
Please give me ideas..

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Anonymous (Dec12, Wed comment)

Everybody around you is asking you to fake? Time to get rid of them in life and get people who would offer you some sane advice.

Anonymous said...

vinay:-

very hot hot discussions have gone here.

let me share my views.the interviewer can easily understand whether the candidate is real experienced or fake one. if the interviewer feel the candidate have the technical knowledge and can justifies the given task, he would take him. few of my friend got job like that.Before putting fake make yourself technically strong regarding the subject knowledge.then only you can survive after getting job by putting fake experience.

getting job is easy but survival in job is toughest than you thought.

these words not to hurt/blame any
one...

Kumar said...

Hi Pradeep, I am currently looking for Software Testing as a fresher and I am not finding any opportunities as a fresher. And I even completed Software Testing course. One of my friend xxx(don't want to reveal identity) got the job in big mnc with 2 years of fake experience with a package of 3.6LPA. Now he is advising to put fake., but I said no. I just want to be honest and genuine but not fake. Even if I fail 100 times, I will never give up but I will try 101 time. My inspiration behind this is the persons "nick vujicic" and you can also know about him through google.

Finally, I just want to send my profile to your email and hope you help me out with this not just with sympathy but if you feel i suit for this position.

Kumar said...

Hi Pradeep,
The one thing you are asking in for freshers recruitment is to have good PH score. Only very very very less people might have written PH. What about other's who want to kick start their career like me in one of the best testing companies in India as fresher?Think about this.

Pradeep Soundararajan said...

@Kumar,

That is a good question you ask. Who said we do not hire freshers unless they have a good Ph score? You just need to be smart enough to get in. How can you do it?

Kiran Kumar said...

Thanks for your response. Yes, I know the hiring procedure which is unique for your company only. We need to test open source project and need to send test report. If it impresses you, we would be called. That is what I am trying to do Pradeep Sir. I am eagerly awaiting an opportunity to kick start my career with Moolya.